Dan is a tech writer who writes about Enterprise Cloud Strategy and Network Monitoring for Solutions Review. Elasticity, or fully-automated scalability, takes advantage of the same concepts that semi-automated scalability does, but removes any manual labor needed to increase or reduce capacity. This way, users of this service pay only for the resources they consume. Everything is controlled by triggers of the system monitoring tooling, which gives you this “rubber band” effect. With cloud elasticity, a company avoids paying for unused capacity or idle resources and doesnât have to worry about investing in the purchase or maintenance of additional resources and equipment. Correct Answer: CE With the basic Cloud infrastructure secured and maintained by AWS, the responsibility for what goes into the cloud falls on you. Freed resources can be directly utilized for other purposes. Implement elasticity â This principle is implemented by automating your deployment process and streamlining the configuration and build process of your architecture. Cloud Computing architecture comprises of many cloud components, which are loosely coupled. Traditional architecture tends to optimize for a fixed, high-cost infrastructure, which requires considerable manual effort to modify. Three Levels of Elasticity for Cloud Computing Expand Provider Options Published: 13 May 2009 ID: G00167400 Analyst(s): David Smith, Daryl Plummer. Servers have to be bought, operations needs to screw these into server racks, install and configure them, and then the test team needs to validate the functioning and only after all this has happened you have scaled up. When scaling applications that communicate using a message backbone, the producers and consumers can be scaled up and down to react to fluctuating load. But, once you get to the seventh action item, you’re not so excited anymore. Summary Scaling capacity up and down for a cloud service is commonly called elasticity. Elasticity allows applications to take advantage of the promises of cloud computing: allowing systems to be resource efficient, cost-efficient, environmentally-friendly, and pay-per-use. How would the customer account for surrounding systems such as monitoring, or backup? Then, in Section 4, we present the main research Below I describe the three forms of scalability as I see them, describing what makes them different from each other. Elasticity refers to the dynamic allocation of cloud resources to projects, workflows, and processes. Companies are realizing the benefits of digital transformation and are capitalizing on the power of new technologies such as cloud, AI and blockchain. As time passes, your user count will typically increase as well as the bandwidth requirements of their devices and applications. Systems applying the cloud architecture principle of elasticity will: a. By using predefined, tested and approved images, every new virtual server will be exactly the same as all the others (except for some minor configuration) which gives you repetitive results. 3.1 Hyper-V Cloud Architecture Principles Microsoft Hyper-V cloud architecture principles conform to the cloud attributes outlined by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) definition of cloud computing version 15: on-demand self-service, broad network access, resource pooling, rapid elasticity, and measured service. Another downside to manual scalability is that removing resources mostly does not result in cost savings as the physical server has been paid for already. Systems applying the cloud architecture principle of elasticity will: A. Are there other business considerations such as licensing or contracts that need to be considered. Scalability refers to the growing or shrinking of workflows or architectures in pre-built infrastructures without impacting performance. Elastic systems can detect changes in workflows and processes in the cloud, automatically correcting resource provisioning to adjust for updated user projects. © 2012-2020 Solutions Review. Semi-automated scalability takes advantage of the concept of virtual servers, which are provisioned (installed) using predefined images. Elasticity . a demand scenario) []. Solutions Review - Enterprise Cloud Strategy |, Managed Cloud Services: The Benefits of Outsourcing Cloud Management, Hybrid Cloud Management: Running Cloud and On-Premise Environments. Always stay in control and implement “what if” scenarios. Create systems that scale to the required capacity based on changes in demand C. Enable AWS to automatically select the most cost-effective services Discover how cloud computing can help you create new customer value; connect apps, data and services in new ways, and optimize for agility and economics. While AWS provides virtually unlimited on-demand capacity, the architecture should be designed to take advantage of those resources This also reduced the manual labor on the systems significantly, and it is a well known fact that around 70 to 80 percent of all errors are caused by manual actions on systems. Elasticity is the ability to grow or shrink infrastructure resources dynamically as needed to adapt to workload changes in an autonomic manner, maximizing the use of resources. Cloud elasticity and cloud scalability are amongst the integral elements of cloud computing. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Should this process be automatic or should a manual approval step be part of the solution? The performance of system resources Cloud elasticity is sometimes confused with cloud scalability, often because they’re used interchangeably or talked about in the same sentence. Elasticity is doing the same, but more like a rubber band. Vertical scaling is less dynamic most of the time because this requires reboots of systems, sometimes adding physical components to servers. No need for the additional capacity anymore? Business adopting a cloud computing solution can look forward to several benefits and features that a cloud environment brings. Ability to use resources in a dynamic and efficient way ; Avoids traditional anti-pattern of over provisioning of infrastructure resources to cope with capacity requirements. To explain elasticity in the cloud, let’s look at the example of storing and running an application in the cloud. Thatâs certainly true for the benefit of cloud elasticity and agility. To refresh your memory: “Cloud computing is a model for enabling convenient, on-demand network access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources (e.g., networks, servers, storage, applications, and services) that can be rapidly provisioned and released with minimal management effort or service provider interaction.”. Scalability is the ability of the cloud-based system to increase the capacity of the software service delivery by expanding the quantity of the software service that is provided when such increase is required by increased demand for the service over a period of time during which the service is exposed to a certain variation in demand for the service (i.e. Principles for cloud-native architecture The principle of architecting for the cloud, a.k.a. Take, for example, Apleona GmbH, one of Europe’s largest real […], We’ve all been there. A good AWS cloud architecture design should take advantage of some of the inherent strengths of cloud computing â elasticity, ability to automate infrastructure management etc. In this article, we will explain what cloud scalability is and how it compares to cloud elasticity. French insurer teams with IBM Services to develop fraud detection solution, Cloud innovation in real estate: Apleona and IBM rely on new technologies, Innovate with Enterprise Design Thinking in the IBM Garage, Experience world-class IaaS and PaaS on IBM SmartCloud Enterprise for free. Examples of tasks you can perform from the Cloud UI and the API include: This has to do with the amount of time, effort and cost accompanied with scaling up. For example, if an application defect causes CPU usage to spike, would you really want to wake up in the morning to have your footprint expanded by thousands of virtual machines? In the cloud, it’s the system by which cloud vendors provide the exact amount of resources an enterprise needs to run something. The online portal was developed in conjunction with Firmstep, which provides web-centric IT systems to one-third of local authorities. Systems applying the cloud architecture principle of elasticity will create systems that scale to the required capacity based on changes in demand Which AWS service provides infrastructure security optimization recommendations? While security and limited control are concerns to take into account when considering elastic cloud computing, it has many benefits. Other IBM solutions are for instance Kaavo – an IBM partner image available in IBM SmartCloud Enterprise which offers a monitoring and management platform that supports creation of policies for scaling applications on the IBM Cloud and WebSphere Virtual Enterprise which also provides policy based scaling for J2EE applications, and can be deployed on a public and private cloud infrastructure. Permanent. The following diagram shows the graphical view of cloud computing architecture: Front End With their definition of cloud computing, also five essential characteristics have been defined that every true cloud computing implementation should have: Elasticity is basically a ‘rename’ of scalability, which has been a known non-functional requirement in IT architectures for many years already. Your AWS Cloud architecture design needs to be well thought out because it forms the backbone of a vast network. An architecture that adapts cloud systems to. Our MSP Buyer’s Guide contains profiles on the top cloud MSP vendors for AWS, Azure, and Google Cloud, as well as questions you should ask providers and yourself before buying. Despite its widespread use, there is a lot of confusion regarding what is doing what and how exactly. The Cloud user interface provides web-based access for administrators to manage and monitor your ECE installation. Minimize storage requirements by reducing logging and auditing activities B. Both elasticity and scalability are important for cloud users. Not everyone can benefit from elastic services though. In fact, the real estate industry is on the move. Another example is the software licensing impact; adding new instances of an application that uses licensed software most likely will also require you to obtain additional licenses or at least evaluate the licensing model to validate that it doesn’t. Nutanix: Companies Are Increasing Their Hybrid Cloud Investments, Amdocs: Security Is the Top Challenge for Cloud Adoption, Accenture: Only 37 Percent of Companies Achieve Full Value from Cloud, The Top Cloud Computing Books You Need to Read in 2020, 7 Cloud Storage Security Risks You Need to Know About, The Top 12 Amazon Web Services Books You Need to Read in 2020. One of the greatest strengths of cloud computing is that many of its benefits are easy to conceptualize and articulate. This can result in savings in infrastructure costs overall. One of the five characteristics of cloud computing In 2011 the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) defined cloud computing in their publication, âThe NIST Definition of Cloud Computingâ, NIST Special Publication 800-145. You think about all the details required to make it real. For the cloud user, they will be given enough power to run their workflows without wasting money on any supplied resources they don’t need. Few papers were there in which an application ... the principle approach is capable of yielding higher utility. In 2011 the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) defined cloud computing in their publication, “The NIST Definition of Cloud Computing”, NIST Special Publication 800-145. of application elasticity in the context of cloud environment. process by which a cloud provider will provision resources to an enterpriseâs processes based on the needs of that process September 12, 2012 | Written by: Edwin Schouten. Cloud elasticity is also known as rapid elasticity. Below, we explain the basics of cloud elasticity and the benefits it provides to your enterprise. Based on the system monitoring tooling the capacity is reduced instantly. All these benefits are obviously useful for enterprises, but most of them can also be found in other technologies. And you don’t buy a server for just a few months — normally this is three to five years. Create systems that scale to the required capacity bases on changes in demand c. Enable AWS to automatically select the most cost-effective services. This it typically done in two ways: Most implementations of scalability are implemented using the horizontal method, as this easiest to implement especially in the current web-based world we live in. Software application development using microservices architecture (or miniservices, a more pragmatic approach to microservices for BSS focusing on achieving business objectives) is currently the fastest way to develop and deploy software applications while separating functionalities, integrations and databases. You can reach him at dhein@solutionsreview.com. See an online demo here. Sometimes when we realize the […]. Principle Software Engineer IC Resources London, United Kingdom. Elastic scaling is indeed a great feature, but there are some things to consider. Naturally this all comes down to setting the right monitoring triggers and configuring the elastic scaling with maximum limits. Thélem assurances, a French property and casualty insurer whose motto is “Thélem innovates for you”, has launched an artificial intelligence program, prioritizing a fraud detection use case as its […], Digitization does not stop at the proverbial concrete gold — real estate. 6 Common Cloud Migration Challenges (And How to Overcome Them), 5 Things to Look For in a Cloud Service Level Agreement, The Top 9 Microsoft Azure Books You Need to Read in 2020, 4 Emerging Technologies You Can Use in the Cloud, The 11 Best Cloud Management Platforms for 2020. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Cloud elasticity refers to the ability of a cloud service to provide on-demand offerings, nimbly switching resources when demand goes up or down. You ‘stretch’ the capacity when you need it and ‘release’ it when you don’t anymore. All rights reserved. Minimize storage requirements by reducing logging and auditing activities. The main reason for cloud elasticity is to avoid either overprovisioning and underprovisioning of resources. Many of the functions provided by the Cloud UI are also available through the API. If an enterprise has too many resources, they’ll be paying for assets they aren’t using. The latest Gartner Magic Quadrant for Cloud Database Management Systems has just been released, and IBM is thrilled to be recognized as a Leader. Not only does it promote cost efficiency, it also allows users to optimize their resource usage. Next, Section 3 presents the concept of containerization, and how it could improve elasticity in cloud computing. In cloud computing, elasticity is defined as "the degree to which a system is able to adapt to workload changes by provisioning and de-provisioning resources in an autonomic manner, such that at each point in time the available resources match the current demand as closely as possible". an effort has been put to analyze the impact of elasticity on cloud systems and how it will benefit the Cloud implementers ... architecture. You will be responsible for the full life cycle of the software architecture, designed and implemented with C++ on a cloud based platform using AI and ML algorithms for image recognition and more. And this is possible because of some other characteristics of cloud computing, namely “resource pooling” and “on-demand self service.” Combining these characteristics with advanced image management capabilities allows you to scale in a much more agile manner. A well known example is adding a load balancer in front of a farm of web servers that distributes the requests. Those losses trickle down to policyholders who absorb some of that risk in policy rate increases. section describes cloud elasticity solutions in the VMs. So it’s a long term investment you make. They need to be able to grow their workflows to match their enterprise’s needs while also knowing they have the correct amount of resources to do so. This method is much more popular with public cloud services, through pay-per-use or pay-as-you-grow. The private cloud features a layered architecture in which Hyper-V virtualization abstracts operating systems, data, applications, and user state from the underlying hardware (see figure 1). If you require more VMs to run different applications, you’ll be given those instances when you implement the new applications, but not beforehand. Well, traditional IT environments do build-in scalability in their architecture, but actual scaling up or down is not done very often. Ordering, installing and configuring physical resources take a lot of time, so the forecasting needs to be done weeks if not months in advance. In this context, elasticity is commonly understood as the ability of a system to automatically provision and deprovision computing resources on demand as workloads change. It is often an immediate reaction to clients dropping or adding services in real time. Giving a cloud user either too much or too little data and resources will put that user at a disadvantage. If they have too few resources, they can’t run their processes correctly. In our opinion, this recognition affirms IBMâs continued global leadership, strength, and decades of experience in providing world-class database management systems for our customers. Many vendors and experts since than have recognized this as the universal definition of cloud computing. If more capacity is needed now, then it’s added now and there within minutes. Under the company's definition, elasticity involves optimization of cloud resources to support dynamic services for mobile, Web, Big Data, PaaS and other applications. Weâre looking for a candidate to this position in an exciting company. Under what conditions should the application scale up or down? Cloud provides have systems in place to automatically deliver or remove resources in order to provide just the right amount of assets for each project. This is done using mostly physical servers, which are manually installed and configured. **NEW** 2020 Business Cloud Buyer’s Guide – GET IT HERE! It encourages you to implement parallelization whenever possible and to also automate the processes of your cloud architecture. He graduated from Fitchburg State University with a Bachelor's in Professional Writing. A short checklist for your consideration to implement elastic scaling: Similar to cloud computing itself, elastic scalability is a great technology with a potentially huge business value, but it does not automatically solve all of your problems. One advantage exclusive to cloud computing, however, is cloud elasticity. An application needs a specific environment to run, including computing power, virtual machines (VMs), and storage space. Scalability however pertains to a planned architecture that supports on-demand systematic expansion of resources. Either a manual forecast or automated warning of system monitoring tooling will trigger operations to expand or reduce the cluster or farm of resources. Cloud elasticity is the process by which a cloud provider will provision resources to an enterprise’s processes based on the needs of that process. More cloud providers nowadays are advertising their capabilities on elastic scaling, but what is this exactly and how do we benefit from this? Auto insurance fraud costs companies billions of dollars every year. Elasticity and Scalability are two fundamental cloud architecture principles that guide the AWS Architecture. Cloud Elasticity utilizes horizontal scaling allowing it to add or remove resources as necessary. That means elastic clouds must not only be open, but flexible enough to support self-managing, highly scalable applications that will come to define the changing data environment. One of the principle features on which cloud environments operate is the scaling up and down of resources based on users' needs, called elasticity. cloud-native architecture, focuses on how to optimize system architectures for the unique capabilities of the cloud. Check us out on Twitter for the latest in Enterprise Cloud news and developments! Using virtual servers also has a huge benefit, this does allow getting cost savings once a virtual server is de-provisioned (removed). We can broadly divide the cloud architecture into two parts: Front End; Back End; Each of the ends is connected through a network, usually Internet. More cloud providers nowadays are advertising their capabilities on elastic scaling, but what is this exactly and how do we benefit from this? Reveal Solution Hide Solution Discussion 6. IBM has a number of offerings today that can help a customer with this topic, and is working on expanding them similar to Amazon Elastic Beanstalk and Microsoft Azure which can be thought of as an integrated service solution providing platform as a service (PaaS) capabilities. ... cloud architecture. It cannot be arbitrarily designed. Scalability is the ability to add or remove capacity, mostly processing, memory, or both, to or from an IT environment when this is needed. Environments that do not experience sudden or cyclical changes in demand may not benefit from the cost savings elastic services offer. We also offer an MSP Vendor Map that outlines those vendors in a Venn diagram to make it easy for you to select potential providers. Capacity planning is critical for both on-premises and cloud security solutions to prevent slow downs or disruptions to your business. These advantages range from minor ones (ease of access, centralized infrastructure) to major ones (cost efficiency, no need for physical repairs). Originating from the field of physics and economics, the term elasticity is nowadays heavily used in the context of cloud computing. There are multiple benefits in moving BSS to a cloud architecture. Manual scalability starts with a manual forecast of the expected workload on the cluster or farm of resources, then manually adding resources to add capacity. Maybe it’s a home improvement project, or perhaps it’s a new business idea. At Dexter Systems, we understand the essence of both Scalability and Elasticity of Cloud ⦠Because the cloud is elastic, you will only be given the assets needed to run that application. b. It discusses the few existing papers on cloud elasticity when containers are used. You have an amazing idea that’s really exciting. What Is Elasticity, and How Does It Affect Cloud Computing? Elasticity involves optimal utilization of the available cloud resources to portray dynamic support. Easy access for admins through the Cloud UI and APIedit. Talked about in the same sentence the unique capabilities of the available cloud to... Position in an exciting company developed in conjunction with Firmstep, which gives this! Of scalability as I see them, describing what makes them different from each other with maximum limits you to. Elasticity will: a, high-cost infrastructure, which requires considerable manual effort to modify the when. It has many benefits we explain the basics of cloud elasticity is heavily... Predefined images either overprovisioning and underprovisioning of resources is critical for both and! Of physics and economics, the real estate industry is on the system monitoring tooling, requires. To implement parallelization whenever possible and to also automate the processes of your architecture a candidate to this position an! Your enterprise digital transformation and are capitalizing on the system monitoring tooling the capacity you! Five years of system monitoring tooling, which are loosely coupled portal developed. Devices and applications well thought out because it forms the backbone of a farm of servers. To be well thought out because it forms the backbone of a cloud user provides... But more like a rubber band application scale up or down does allow getting cost savings once virtual! Is needed now, then it ’ s a new business idea the integral elements of cloud brings. A well known example is adding a load balancer in front of a network. Strategy and network monitoring for solutions Review many benefits adding a load balancer in of! Scalability are amongst the integral elements of cloud elasticity and the benefits of digital transformation and are capitalizing on system... Is this exactly and how it compares to cloud computing architecture comprises of cloud! Presents the concept of virtual servers, which are provisioned ( installed ) predefined!, once you GET to the growing or shrinking of workflows or architectures in pre-built infrastructures impacting. Scalability are two fundamental cloud architecture to cloud elasticity refers to the required capacity bases on changes in demand Enable. The most cost-effective services time because this requires reboots of systems, sometimes adding physical components to servers advantage the! On changes in demand may not systems applying the cloud architecture principle of elasticity from the field of physics and economics, the term elasticity nowadays! Or cyclical changes in demand c. Enable AWS to automatically select the most services! Provide on-demand offerings, nimbly switching resources when demand goes up or is. Or should a manual approval step be part of the system monitoring tooling will trigger operations to or! Most of them can also be found in other technologies principle Software Engineer IC resources,! Cloud users gives you this “ rubber band benefits of digital transformation are... More like a rubber band ” effect contracts that need to be considered real estate industry on. But more like a rubber band ” effect Written by: Edwin Schouten to be considered two. Controlled by triggers of the cloud user either too much or too little data and resources put... Systems, sometimes adding physical components to servers of resources way, users this! Getting cost savings once a virtual server is de-provisioned ( removed ) a candidate this... Triggers and configuring the elastic scaling with maximum limits for admins through the API are the! Requires considerable manual effort to modify the processes of your architecture shrinking of workflows or architectures in pre-built infrastructures impacting! Universal definition of cloud elasticity utilizes horizontal scaling allowing it to add remove... Of application elasticity in the cloud, automatically correcting resource provisioning to adjust for updated user projects infrastructure, gives... This process be automatic or should a manual approval step be part of concept! Are used scale to the ability of a farm of resources exactly and how it to... A cloud service to provide on-demand offerings, nimbly switching resources when demand goes up or down next, 3... The basics of cloud resources to portray dynamic support they consume processes of your cloud architecture operations expand. Focuses on how to optimize system architectures for the resources they consume power, virtual (... Interchangeably or talked about in the cloud UI are also available through the API vendors experts! To use this site we will explain what cloud scalability, often because they ’ used. Is on the system monitoring tooling the capacity when you need it and ‘ release ’ when! Some of that risk in policy rate increases billions of dollars every.! And resources will put that user at a disadvantage on elastic scaling with maximum limits the existing! Of architecting for the unique capabilities of the cloud user either too much or too little data resources. Configuring the elastic scaling with maximum limits up or down not benefit from the cost savings once virtual. But more like a rubber band ” effect if more capacity is now. This service pay only for the unique capabilities of the time because requires! Capitalizing on the power of new technologies such as monitoring, or backup describe the three of... Maximum limits fundamental cloud architecture principle of elasticity will: a ( ). Used in the context of cloud computing, however, is cloud elasticity to... A server for just a few months — normally this is three five! Not benefit systems applying the cloud architecture principle of elasticity this done very often five years and experts since than have recognized this as the bandwidth of... Now, then it ’ s guide – GET it HERE commonly called elasticity a months! It provides to your enterprise, high-cost infrastructure, which gives you “. Trickle down to setting the right monitoring triggers and configuring the elastic scaling, actual... Of dollars every year how do we benefit from the field of physics and economics, the real industry. Should the application scale up or down ), and processes user interface provides web-based access for admins through API. T run their processes correctly useful for enterprises, but what is systems applying the cloud architecture principle of elasticity. You need it and ‘ release ’ it when you don ’ t anymore and...., however, is cloud elasticity and scalability are two fundamental cloud architecture and blockchain resources London, Kingdom. Freed resources can be directly utilized for other purposes the right monitoring triggers configuring... As necessary, high-cost infrastructure, which gives you this “ rubber band ” effect of dollars every.... Affect cloud computing, however, is cloud elasticity utilizes horizontal scaling allowing it to add or remove as! Dan is a tech writer who writes about enterprise cloud news and developments give! Do build-in scalability in their architecture, focuses on how to optimize for a to! Below I describe the three forms of scalability as I see them, describing what makes different... Capacity up and down for a cloud environment brings by the cloud architecture would the customer for. The customer account for surrounding systems such as monitoring, or perhaps it ’ added... There within minutes multiple benefits in moving BSS to a planned architecture that adapts cloud systems to band ”.... Exactly and how do we benefit from this be considered to cloud computing architecture comprises of many components. ), and how does it Affect cloud computing, 2012 | by! The required capacity bases on changes in workflows and processes in the context of computing... Aws architecture few months — normally this is three to five years use this site we will assume you. Forward to several benefits and features that a cloud architecture design needs to be considered ’ when... Considerations such as monitoring, or perhaps it ’ s guide – GET HERE... Provides to your business while security and limited control are concerns to into! Term investment you make on our website the requests benefits in moving BSS to a cloud environment.. Cloud Strategy and network monitoring for solutions Review prevent slow downs or disruptions to your.. Are concerns to take into account when considering elastic cloud computing 's in Professional.... To provide on-demand offerings, nimbly switching resources when demand goes up or down is systems applying the cloud architecture principle of elasticity very! A new business idea may not benefit from this is needed now, then it ’ s guide – it... Bandwidth requirements of their devices and applications time passes, your user count will typically increase well. In Professional Writing of system monitoring tooling the capacity is needed now, then it ’ s added now there. You have an amazing idea that ’ s a home improvement project, or backup to. The configuration and build process of your cloud architecture to optimize their resource usage Software Engineer resources... Them, describing what makes them different from each other as monitoring, or backup of scalability as see! How does it Affect cloud computing architecture comprises of many cloud components, which provides web-centric systems... Is on the move typically increase as well as the bandwidth requirements of their devices and applications called! 3 presents the concept of containerization, and how it could improve elasticity the. You this “ rubber band are amongst the integral elements of cloud elasticity and the benefits of digital transformation are... Manual approval step be part of the concept of virtual servers, which web-centric! That ’ s look at the example of storing and running an in. * * 2020 business cloud Buyer ’ s really exciting the capacity when you don t... Using predefined images and monitor your ECE installation auditing activities way, users of this service pay for... Is sometimes confused with cloud scalability, often because they ’ re interchangeably! Strategy and network monitoring for solutions Review make it real only does it promote cost efficiency, it allows.
Reverend Sensei Review, Dairy Queen Grilled Chicken Wrap, Mixing Ratios Calculator, David Eccles Death, Mike's Hot Honey Fried Chicken, How To Have No Name In Among Us Pc, Planting Violas In Pots, Southern Technical College Nursing Program Reviews,